Here and There
79
Here and There
Joshua V. Scher's 'Here and There' is not a casual read; it demands active participation from its reader. The book's strength lies in its bold reframing of familiar metaphysical concepts, particularly its examination of the duality between the observer and the observed. Scher’s insistence on the subjective nature of experience, as seen in his treatment of the concept of 'presence,' is particularly compelling. However, the work sometimes suffers from a density that can make tracing the thread of argument challenging, especially in sections discussing the mechanics of perception. A passage that particularly stands out is the exploration of how 'place' is less a geographical coordinate and more a state of consciousness. Ultimately, 'Here and There' offers a valuable, albeit demanding, perspective for serious seekers of esoteric knowledge.
📝 Description
79
### What It Is 'Here and There' by Joshua V. Scher presents a unique exploration of consciousness and perception, drawing from esoteric traditions without adhering to a single dogma. The book challenges conventional boundaries of thought, presenting concepts that invite readers to question their fundamental understanding of reality. It functions as a philosophical primer and a practical guide for those seeking to expand their mental horizons.
### Who It's For This work is intended for the dedicated student of consciousness, the speculative philosopher, and the practitioner of contemplative arts. Readers who are already familiar with concepts from Hermeticism, Gnosticism, or Western esotericism will find fertile ground for cross-referencing and deeper inquiry. It is for those who appreciate rigorous intellectual engagement with metaphysical ideas.
### Historical Context Published in 2015, 'Here and There' emerged during a period of renewed interest in comparative spirituality and esoteric philosophy, following the foundational work of figures like Manly P. Hall and the resurgence of interest in Jungian psychology. It sits within a lineage of texts that seek to synthesize disparate philosophical and mystical traditions, offering a contemporary voice to perennial questions about existence and awareness.
### Key Concepts The book engages with ideas of subjective reality, the nature of the self, and the interconnectedness of all phenomena. It posits that the perceived separation between internal experience and external reality is a construct, and that true understanding comes from recognizing their unified essence. The work offers frameworks for contemplating these ideas through various lenses, encouraging personal exploration.
💡 Why Read This Book?
• Gain a nuanced understanding of the interplay between subjective experience and objective reality, as explored through Scher's concept of 'anchoring' in the text. • Develop a more critical lens for examining the constructed nature of perception, informed by the book's specific discussions on the self in relation to the external world. • Discover potential frameworks for personal contemplative practice, inspired by the book's unique approach to the 'here and there' dichotomy, first published in 2015.
⭐ Reader Reviews
Honest opinions from readers who have explored this book.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What esoteric traditions does Joshua V. Scher draw upon in 'Here and There'?
The book references concepts found in Western Hermeticism and Gnosticism, but it does not strictly adhere to any single tradition. Scher synthesizes ideas to explore consciousness and reality.
What is the central philosophical challenge presented by 'Here and There'?
The primary challenge is the dismantling of the perceived separation between internal subjective experience and external objective reality, urging readers to consider their unified nature.
When was 'Here and There' first published?
Joshua V. Scher's 'Here and There' was first published in 2015, positioning it as a contemporary contribution to esoteric literature.
Is 'Here and There' suitable for beginners in esoteric studies?
While accessible, the book's depth and conceptual rigor are best appreciated by those with some prior exposure to philosophical or esoteric concepts.
What is the book's approach to 'presence'?
Scher's work explores 'presence' not as a static state but as an active engagement with reality, challenging the notion of passive observation and emphasizing the observer's role.
Does the book offer practical exercises for readers?
While not a manual of explicit exercises, 'Here and There' provides conceptual frameworks and contemplative prompts that can guide practical personal exploration and insight.
🔮 Key Themes & Symbolism
Subjectivity of Reality
The work posits that perceived reality is fundamentally shaped by the observer's consciousness. Scher argues against a fixed, objective external world independent of awareness. This perspective aligns with certain Gnostic ideas of a created, thus potentially illusory, material realm, while also echoing Hermetic principles of 'As Above, So Below,' suggesting a deep correspondence between inner states and outer phenomena. The book encourages a re-evaluation of what constitutes 'real' by examining the role of perception in constructing our world.
The Observer-Observed Dichotomy
'Here and There' directly confronts the apparent separation between the individual experiencing (the observer) and the world being experienced (the observed). Scher suggests this division is a conceptual artifact, not an inherent truth. This theme resonates with contemplative practices across various traditions that aim to dissolve such boundaries, leading to a sense of unity or non-duality. The book explores how this perceived separation influences our understanding of self and existence.
Consciousness as a Construct
Scher examines consciousness not as a passive recipient of information but as an active force that structures experience. The book delves into how mental frameworks, beliefs, and the very act of 'being present' contribute to the formation of our perceived reality. This echoes philosophical inquiries into the nature of mind, reminiscent of certain idealist philosophies and esoteric schools that view consciousness as primary, the ground of all being.
The Nature of Place and Being
The title itself, 'Here and There,' points to an exploration of spatiality and subjective location. Scher questions whether 'here' and 'there' are merely physical coordinates or can represent distinct states of consciousness or being. This abstract concept of 'place' as a function of awareness is a recurring motif, inviting readers to consider their own sense of grounding and belonging not just physically, but psychically and spiritually.
💬 Memorable Quotes
“The boundary between 'here' and 'there' is drawn by attention.”
— This paraphrase suggests that our perception of separation in space is a function of where we direct our focus. It implies that the very act of observing or experiencing creates the distinction, rather than the distinction existing independently.
“Reality is not what is, but what is perceived to be.”
— This conceptual quote highlights the book's emphasis on subjective experience. It posits that our understanding and interaction with the world are dictated by our perceptual filters, challenging the notion of an absolute, objective truth accessible without interpretation.
“To be present is to collapse the distance.”
— This paraphrased idea suggests that true presence or mindfulness dissolves the perceived gap between oneself and the environment or subject of attention. It points to a state of unified awareness where observer and observed are no longer distinct.
“The self is not a fixed point, but a field of awareness.”
— This interpretation frames the self as dynamic and fluid, not a static entity. It suggests that our identity is an ever-changing landscape of consciousness rather than a singular, unchanging core, aligning with non-dualistic philosophical perspectives.
“Distance is a measure of consciousness, not of space.”
— This conceptual statement reframes our understanding of separation. It proposes that the feeling or perception of 'distance' is not an objective spatial reality but a subjective experience tied to the state or scope of one's awareness.
🌙 Esoteric Significance
Tradition
While not strictly confined to a single tradition, 'Here and There' draws heavily from the philosophical underpinnings of Western Esotericism, particularly Hermeticism and Gnosticism. It engages with the Hermetic principle of correspondence ('As Above, So Below') and Gnostic ideas concerning the illusory nature of the material world and the importance of gnosis (direct knowledge) for liberation. Scher's work can be seen as a contemporary articulation of perennial philosophy, seeking to synthesize these ancient insights into a framework relevant to modern consciousness.
Symbolism
The book frequently employs the symbolic dichotomy of 'here' and 'there' to represent not just spatial separation but also the perceived division between subjective consciousness and objective reality. The concept of 'anchoring' serves as a symbolic tool for grounding oneself in awareness, suggesting a point of stability within the flux of perception. The 'field of awareness' can be seen as a symbolic representation of the interconnectedness of all phenomena, where individual consciousness is not isolated but part of a larger energetic matrix.
Modern Relevance
Contemporary thinkers in fields like consciousness studies, transpersonal psychology, and even certain branches of theoretical physics echo Scher's exploration of subjective reality. Practices focused on mindfulness, non-duality, and integral theory often touch upon similar themes of observer-dependent reality and the dissolution of perceived boundaries. 'Here and There' provides a philosophical text that can inform practitioners of meditation, lucid dreaming, and those interested in the philosophical implications of quantum mechanics.
👥 Who Should Read This Book
• Students of Hermeticism and Gnosticism seeking contemporary philosophical interpretations of core concepts concerning reality and consciousness. • Philosophers and thinkers interested in the subjective nature of experience and the observer's role in constructing perceived reality. • Meditative practitioners and contemplative individuals looking for conceptual frameworks to deepen their understanding of presence and non-duality.
📜 Historical Context
Published in 2015, Joshua V. Scher's 'Here and There' emerged in a landscape where esoteric thought was increasingly accessible online, yet often fragmented. This period saw a resurgence of interest in consciousness studies, fueled by neuroscience and psychology, alongside a continued engagement with older traditions like Hermeticism and Gnosticism. Scher's work positioned itself within this milieu, offering a synthesis that moved beyond strict adherence to any single lineage. Contemporaries exploring similar themes of consciousness and perception included figures like Daniel Pinchbeck, who, though often focused on psychedelics, also grappled with altered states and reality construction. Unlike purely academic texts or dogmatic spiritual manuals, 'Here and There' sought a middle ground, aiming for intellectual rigor while remaining open to speculative inquiry. Its reception was likely among niche circles of independent thinkers and esoteric practitioners, reflecting the ongoing dialogue between established academic discourse and emergent philosophical explorations.
📔 Journal Prompts
The concept of 'anchoring' and its role in stabilizing awareness.
The perceived distance between 'here' and 'there' as a measure of consciousness.
How the 'field of awareness' shapes your understanding of self and reality.
The implications of reality being constructed by perception.
Re-evaluating the observer-observed dichotomy in your daily experiences.
🗂️ Glossary
Anchoring
A concept within the book suggesting a method or state of being that stabilizes consciousness and grounds the individual in present awareness, countering mental drift or dissociation.
Field of Awareness
The book's term for the encompassing consciousness in which all phenomena, subjective and objective, are perceived to exist; implies interconnectedness.
Observer-Observed
The fundamental duality explored in the text, referring to the perceived separation between the entity that perceives and the reality that is perceived.
Presence
A state of being fully engaged with the current moment and reality, as explored in the book, often linked to the dissolution of temporal and spatial divisions.
Subjective Reality
The world as experienced and interpreted by an individual consciousness, contrasted with the notion of an objective, independent reality.
Here and There
The central conceptual framework of the book, representing perceived spatial or existential separation that the work aims to deconstruct.
Consciousness Construct
The idea that our experience of reality is actively built or structured by the nature and limitations of our consciousness.
