The devil and commodity fetishism in South America
79
The devil and commodity fetishism in South America
Michael Taussig's 1986 exploration of the devil and commodity fetishism in South America is a startlingly original piece of scholarship that refuses easy categorization. Taussig’s strength lies in his ability to connect the abstract machinery of Marxist critique with the visceral, often terrifying, realities of lived experience. The ethnographic accounts, particularly those concerning local interpretations of economic exchange and the figure of the devil as a personification of exploitative power, are compelling. He masterfully illustrates how capitalism, far from being a purely rational system, infiltrates and reconfigures belief systems. A limitation, however, is the density of the theoretical prose, which at times can obscure the potent ethnographic material. The passage detailing the "white magic" of the market, where the sheer force of exchange obscures its social relations, exemplifies this tension between theoretical ambition and immediate impact. It is a demanding but ultimately rewarding examination of how the sacred and the profane intertwine in the global economy.
📝 Description
79
### What It Is Michael Taussig's "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America" is a dense ethnographic and Marxist critique that examines the enduring power of capitalist logic and its relationship with the mystical, particularly the figure of the devil, in the South American context. First published in 1986, the work moves beyond abstract economic theory to ground its analysis in the lived experiences and cultural understandings of people grappling with the alienating forces of market economies. Taussig employs a unique style, blending anthropological fieldwork with theoretical exegesis to uncover how pre-capitalist beliefs and practices are reconfigured and sometimes co-opted by the expansion of commodity culture.
### Who It's For This book is intended for readers who appreciate interdisciplinary scholarship that bridges anthropology, Marxism, and cultural studies. It will appeal to those interested in the psychological and spiritual dimensions of economic systems, particularly how abstract market forces manifest in local belief structures and social relations. Scholars and students of Latin American studies, economic anthropology, and critical theory will find its ethnographic detail and theoretical rigor particularly valuable. It is for those willing to engage with challenging texts that explore the darker, more occult aspects of modern economic life.
### Historical Context Published in 1986, "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America" emerged during a period of intense debate within Marxist thought regarding the nature of value, alienation, and the cultural impact of capitalism. Taussig's work offered a counterpoint to more economistic interpretations, drawing on a tradition of critical theory that acknowledged the power of symbolism and belief. His engagement with the concept of fetishism, famously explored by Karl Marx in "Das Kapital," here takes on a more visceral, almost occult dimension. The book was a significant contribution to the ethnography of capitalism, particularly in its detailed look at South American societies adapting to global market forces, a topic also explored by scholars like Arturo Escobar in his critiques of development.
### Key Concepts The central concepts Taussig interrogates include commodity fetishism, the devil as a symbol of alienated labor and exploitative economic relations, and the re-enchantment of the world through capitalist penetration. He explores how the seemingly mundane act of buying and selling can be imbued with magical or diabolical connotations when it disrupts established social orders and introduces new forms of social power. The work also delves into the concept of "mimesis," or the imitation of the other, as a strategy for understanding and potentially resisting the dominant economic logic. Taussig's analysis frequently returns to the specificities of South American cultural landscapes, demonstrating how universal economic processes are shaped by local histories and mythologies.
💡 Why Read This Book?
• Understand the symbolic power of the devil in capitalist societies, learning how Taussig connects this figure to the alienating effects of labor and exchange, as seen in his analysis of South American peasant economies. • Grasp the concept of "commodity fetishism" beyond Marx's initial formulation, seeing how Taussig applies it to local belief systems and the "white magic" of market transactions. • Explore the intersection of anthropology and economics through Taussig's field research, discovering how specific cultural contexts in South America shape the experience of capitalist expansion.
why_read
⭐ Reader Reviews
Honest opinions from readers who have explored this book.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core argument of "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America"?
The book argues that capitalism's expansion into South America doesn't simply replace older belief systems but often reconfigures them. Taussig shows how the devil and other mystical figures become potent symbols for understanding the alienating and exploitative aspects of commodity fetishism and market logic.
When was "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America" first published?
The book was first published in 1986, a significant year for critical theory and ethnographic studies examining the cultural impact of global capitalism.
What does Taussig mean by 'commodity fetishism' in this context?
Taussig extends Marx's concept to explore how commodities, in their exchange, take on a life of their own, obscuring the social relations of production. In South America, this fetishism is often imbued with spiritual or diabolical meanings, making the market itself seem like a site of occult power.
Which regions of South America does Taussig focus on?
Taussig's ethnographic work draws heavily from regions in South America, including Colombia, examining how local populations experience and interpret the intrusion of market economies and Western capitalism.
How does "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism" relate to other works on capitalism and culture?
It stands in dialogue with Marxist thinkers like Marx and later theorists of ideology and culture. Ethnographically, it complements studies on globalization and local resistance, offering a unique perspective on the 'enchantment' of the modern economy.
Is this book suitable for beginners in economic anthropology?
While rigorous, the book's ethnographic richness makes it accessible to determined beginners. However, some familiarity with Marxist theory and anthropological concepts would enhance the reading experience. It's a foundational text for understanding capitalism's cultural dimensions.
🔮 Key Themes & Symbolism
Capitalism and the Occult
Taussig investigates how the expansion of capitalist markets in South America leads to a re-enchantment of the world, not through traditional spirituality, but through the seemingly magical and often diabolical logic of exchange. He posits that the abstract forces of the market, which obscure the human labor and social relations behind commodities, can be understood through the lens of the occult. The devil emerges as a potent symbol for the exploitative and alienating aspects of this economic system, representing the hidden powers that govern economic life, much like a sorcerer's pact.
Commodity Fetishism Reimagined
Extending Marx's analysis of commodity fetishism, Taussig focuses on how it manifests in specific cultural contexts. He moves beyond the simple idea that commodities appear to have intrinsic value, arguing that in places like South America, the process of exchange itself takes on a fetishistic character. This "white magic" of the market creates a sense of wonder and power, while simultaneously masking the underlying social inequalities and the coercive nature of capitalist production. The book explores how local beliefs interact with and are transformed by this process.
Mimesis and Social Transformation
A crucial concept in Taussig's work is mimesis, the imitation of the other. He explores how individuals and communities under pressure from capitalist encroachment adopt or imitate the practices, beliefs, and even the very logic of the dominant economic system. This can be a strategy for survival, a form of resistance, or a way of making sense of overwhelming social change. Taussig examines how imitation, particularly in relation to the devil or the market's power, can be both a source of alienation and a potential, albeit complex, avenue for understanding and critique.
The Devil as Economic Symbol
In "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America," the figure of the devil is not merely a religious icon but a powerful metaphor for the destructive and alienating forces of capitalism. Taussig's ethnographic research reveals how local populations, particularly peasants and workers, interpret the intrusion of market economies through the lens of diabolical pacts and exploitative powers. The devil embodies the hidden costs, the exploitation of labor, and the sense of being controlled by unseen economic forces that characterize the transition to capitalism.
💬 Memorable Quotes
“The devil is the embodiment of what is happening to the world.”
— This interpretation highlights Taussig's central thesis that the figure of the devil serves as a potent symbol for the destructive and alienating forces unleashed by the expansion of global capitalism, particularly in the South American context he examines.
“The magic of the market is a form of white magic.”
— This paraphrased concept suggests that Taussig views the seemingly miraculous ability of the market to transform goods and create value as a kind of enchantment. However, it's 'white magic' in its ability to obscure the underlying social relations and exploitative practices, making the market appear benign.
“There is a fetishism of commodities in capitalist society.”
— This is a direct reference to Marx's concept. Taussig expands upon it by showing how this fetishism, where commodities seem to have inherent value independent of labor, takes on specific cultural and even spiritual dimensions in the South American societies he studied.
“Mimesis is the imitation of the other.”
— This definition points to Taussig's exploration of how people under pressure from dominant forces (like capitalism) adopt or mimic those forces. This imitation can be a survival strategy, a way of making sense of the world, or a complex form of engagement with power.
“The devil is the symbol of the social relations of capitalist production.”
— This interpretation emphasizes Taussig's unique use of the devil figure not just as a religious entity, but as a personification of the exploitative and alienating social structures inherent in the capitalist mode of production, particularly as experienced in his fieldwork.
🌙 Esoteric Significance
Tradition
While not explicitly part of a singular esoteric lineage like Hermeticism or Gnosticism, Taussig's work taps into a broader vein of critical thought that explores the hidden, often darker, forces at play in societal structures. His examination of the devil as a symbol of alienation and exploitation echoes themes found in Gnostic critiques of worldly power structures and the concept of a demiurge. The book engages with the idea that economic systems can possess a 'spirit' or 'logic' that operates almost supernaturally, a concept resonant with certain occult philosophies that seek to understand and manipulate unseen forces.
Symbolism
The primary symbol interrogated is the Devil, which Taussig reinterprets not as a purely religious figure but as a personification of capitalist exploitation, alienation, and the hidden, often coercive, social relations that underpin commodity exchange. Another key motif is the "white magic" of the market, representing the seemingly miraculous and self-regulating power of capitalism that obscures its own social construction. The concept of "mimesis," or imitation, also functions symbolically, illustrating how individuals adopt the logic of their oppressors as a means of survival or understanding.
Modern Relevance
Taussig's work continues to be relevant for contemporary scholars and practitioners interested in the intersection of economics, culture, and psychology. Thinkers exploring the 'spiritual' dimensions of consumerism, the psychological effects of neoliberalism, and the cultural impact of globalization often draw upon his insights. His analysis of how abstract economic forces manifest in local belief systems and social practices remains pertinent for understanding phenomena like the rise of conspiracy theories related to global finance or the cultural anxieties surrounding technological advancement and market dominance.
👥 Who Should Read This Book
• Students of economic anthropology and critical theory seeking to understand the cultural dimensions of capitalism, particularly its impact on non-Western societies. • Scholars of Latin American studies interested in how local belief systems interact with and are transformed by global market forces. • Readers fascinated by the symbolic and psychological aspects of economics, who want to explore how concepts like fetishism and exploitation can be understood through mystical or occult lenses.
📜 Historical Context
Published in 1986, Michael Taussig's "The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America" emerged as a significant intervention in the anthropology of capitalism and Marxist theory. The era was marked by ongoing debates about globalization, dependency theory, and the cultural impact of market economies, particularly in the Global South. Taussig's work offered a counterpoint to more structuralist or purely economic analyses by foregrounding the symbolic, spiritual, and even occult dimensions of capitalist penetration. His exploration of commodity fetishism, building on Karl Marx's foundational ideas, took on a unique ethnographic and almost mystical quality. He engaged with intellectual currents that acknowledged the power of belief systems in shaping economic realities. Key contemporaries in anthropological and critical theory, such as Arturo Escobar and Jean Baudrillard, were also examining the cultural transformations wrought by modernity and consumerism, though Taussig's specific focus on the devil and the 'enchantment' of the market provided a distinct and provocative perspective.
📔 Journal Prompts
The devil's symbolic role in capitalist alienation.
Reflecting on the 'white magic' of market exchange.
Instances of mimesis in contemporary economic behavior.
The re-enchantment of the world through commodity fetishism.
Personal experiences with the occult aspects of finance.
🗂️ Glossary
Commodity Fetishism
A concept from Marx where commodities appear to have intrinsic value, and their exchange obscures the social relations of production and the labor involved in their creation.
Mimesis
The imitation of the other. Taussig uses it to describe how individuals and communities adopt the practices, logic, or symbols of dominant powers, especially in response to capitalist expansion.
White Magic of the Market
Taussig's term for the seemingly miraculous and self-regulating power of capitalist markets that can obscure the underlying social inequalities and exploitative relationships.
Devil
In Taussig's work, the devil serves as a potent symbol for the alienating, exploitative, and hidden forces inherent in capitalist economic systems and their impact on social life.
Re-enchantment
The process by which seemingly rational or secular systems, like capitalism, acquire mystical, spiritual, or occult dimensions in the way they are perceived and experienced by people.
Alienation
A state of estrangement from one's labor, its product, oneself, and other people, often seen as a consequence of capitalist production and market logic.
Ethnography
The study and systematic recording of human cultures; descriptive work concerning a particular human society or group.
